Find the Best Medicare Agents in all
Our top 10 list features verified, licensed, and insured medicare agent professionals. Rankings are based on human research, insurance verification, and public record audits.
Top 10 Medicare Agent Companies
Verified professionals ranked by our comprehensive research methodology
Sooner State Advisors
Sooner State Senior Advisors is a local independent insurance brokerage in Norman specializing in senior health insurance solutions. Licensed brokers help clients navigate Medicare plans, Medicaid assistance, and individual health coverage by comparing options from most major carriers. Services include personalized plan selection, checks for Extra Help and Social Security refunds, food or gas card eligibility, dental and vision benefits, and flexible in-home or public consultations.
Pros
- Provides personalized, clear explanations of complex Medicare and Medicaid options with a client-first approach and no high-pressure sales
Cons
- Standard business hours limited to Monday-Friday 9:00 am to 5:00 pm with weekends closed
Boomer Medicare Help
Boomer Medicare Help, LLC is a licensed Medicare agency providing clear, no-pressure guidance on Medicare options including Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Part D prescription plans. Serving clients in Oklahoma, Kansas, Texas, Arkansas, and Louisiana with personalized consultations, educational resources, secure enrollment assistance, and ongoing annual plan reviews.
Pros
- Provides clear, unbiased explanations of Medicare options including Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans using plain language and official Medicare.gov resources
Cons
- Primarily a single-agent independent practice which may limit availability during peak enrollment periods compared to larger agencies
Oklahoma Health Options, LLC
Oklahoma Health Options, LLC is an independent health insurance brokerage founded in 2016 that helps individuals, families, self-employed people, and small businesses across Oklahoma find suitable coverage. Services include Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplements, prescription drug plans, individual and family plans, group health, supplemental insurance, cancer care, dental, vision, life, long-term care, and Native American plans. The team provides free enrollment assistance, plan comparisons, personalized recommendations, claims support, and year-round guidance while shopping multiple carriers.
Pros
- Independent brokerage that shops multiple carriers to match clients with suitable Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and other health plans
Cons
- Small team size may limit availability during peak enrollment periods
OK Medicare Help
OK Medicare Help is a local independent Medicare agency based in Tulsa, OK, providing zero-cost, no-obligation assistance with Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap), Part D prescription plans, and Special Needs Plans across Oklahoma.
Pros
- Operates a collaborative team network of local, licensed Oklahoma agents.
Cons
- Does not maintain active branded profiles on major consumer review aggregators like Yelp or BBB.
Navigating Medicare
Navigating Medicare is an independent Medicare brokerage agency that strives to make insurance decisions simple. Built on family values of honesty, integrity, togetherness, and support, the agency’s licensed and appointed agents work with multiple insurance providers to help clients compare and select Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, prescription drug, and related plans that fit individual needs rather than forcing clients into a single option. The team provides ongoing support for plan changes, benefits reviews, and comparisons, with a main office in Oklahoma City and additional locations across the state.
Pros
- Owner Ginny Curtis-Gillespie brings nearly 40 years of insurance experience and more than two decades focused specifically on Medicare guidance.
Cons
- Does not offer every plan available in the area and currently represents a limited set of organizations and products rather than the full market.
Cornerstone Insurance Group
Cornerstone Insurance Group is a full-service independent insurance agency offering a variety of personal and business coverages. Licensed agents shop dozens of reputable carriers to find tailored coverage at competitive rates for home, auto, boat, renters, farm, commercial auto and property, business, and life insurance. Serving the entire state of Oklahoma from offices in Tuttle, Kingfisher, and Edmond with a no-pressure approach focused on customer understanding and satisfaction.
Pros
- Independent agency with access to dozens of carriers to shop tailored personal, commercial, farm, and life coverage at competitive rates
Cons
- Standard weekday office hours with earlier Friday close and after-hours by appointment only
Eagle Group Associates, Inc.
Eagle Group Associates, Inc. is a local, family-run independent insurance agency in Oklahoma City serving seniors, individuals, families, and businesses since 1988. The agency specializes in Medicare (Advantage, Supplements/Medigap, and Part D prescription drug plans), individual and family health insurance, life insurance, and employee benefits/group coverage. As an independent agency representing over 70 carriers including Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Humana, and UnitedHealthcare, it compares options to match clients' needs and budgets. The team offers free Medicare classes and workshops, personalized guidance, and treats clients like family, with over 100 years of combined experience.
Pros
- Independent agency representing over 70 carriers including major names like Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Humana, and UnitedHealthcare for side-by-side plan comparisons
Cons
- Standard office hours are limited to weekdays 9:00am-5:30pm with Saturdays by appointment only and Sundays closed
MedicarePrepare
MedicarePrepare is an independent insurance agency and regional FMO specializing in Medicare plans including Supplements, Advantage, and Part D, along with under-65 health insurance, life insurance, final expense, long-term care, annuities, and plans for veterans. Operated by Classic Insurance Agency, LLC with multiple Oklahoma offices including Oklahoma City at Quail Springs Mall, Moore, and Midwest City, plus Tulsa-area and Arkansas locations. Features hundreds of licensed local agents, 26 years of experience, and free personalized enrollment assistance to help clients learn, quote, and enroll.
Pros
- Multiple convenient local offices in the Oklahoma City area including Quail Springs Mall, Moore Crest Foods, and Midwest City for easy in-person consultations
Cons
- Primary hours appear limited to weekdays with weekend appointments by arrangement rather than standard open weekends
Safe Insurance Solutions, LLC
Safe Insurance Solutions, LLC is an independent insurance brokerage with a local office in Oklahoma City offering personalized Medicare, health, life, dental, vision, supplemental, and employer group benefits. Licensed brokers educate clients without pressure or jargon, comparing plans from multiple trusted carriers for individuals, families, seniors, and small businesses via in-person, phone, or virtual meetings.
Pros
- Independent brokerage comparing Medicare Advantage, Medigap, Part D, health, life, and supplemental plans from multiple national carriers
Cons
- Does not offer every plan available in the area and directs clients to Medicare.gov for complete options
Senior Benefits Consulting
Senior Benefits Consulting helps people maximize their Social Security, Medicare, and other benefits. With 25 years of experience, the firm represents all major national and regional insurance carriers and all types of Medicare health plans. The mission is to provide one-on-one consultations to discover what matters most for each person's health coverage and match them with plans that best fit their specific needs, while also assisting with potential additional benefits and income. Free consultations and a free Guide to Medicare Enrollment e-book are offered. Based in Oklahoma City and serving Oklahoma plus multiple other states.
Pros
- Provides free one-on-one consultations focused on matching plans to individual health needs, doctors, medications, and budgets
Cons
- Does not offer every plan available in an area, only those from contracted carriers